Ad Banner
Advertisement by Open Privilege
United States

What's really going on in the real estate market in the U.S

Image Credits: UnsplashImage Credits: Unsplash
  • The clear-cooperation policy, implemented by the NAR in 2020, requires agents to list properties on MLSes within one business day of public marketing, aiming to increase transparency in the real estate market.
  • Major industry players are divided on the policy, with some pushing for its elimination or revision, while others defend its importance for fair access to property information.
  • The outcome of this debate could significantly impact how homes are bought and sold in the future, potentially leading to a more fragmented or more transparent real estate market.

[UNITED STATES] In the ever-evolving landscape of American real estate, a fierce battle is brewing that could fundamentally alter how homes are bought and sold. At the heart of this conflict lies the "clear-cooperation policy," a rule implemented by the National Association of Realtors (NAR) in 2020 that mandates real estate agents to list properties on Multiple Listing Services (MLSes) within one business day of public marketing. This policy, designed to promote transparency and equal access to property information, has become a flashpoint for industry titans and has far-reaching implications for homebuyers, sellers, and agents alike.

The Clear-Cooperation Policy: A Double-Edged Sword

The clear-cooperation policy was introduced with noble intentions. It aimed to create a more transparent real estate market by ensuring that all available properties were visible to potential buyers through centralized databases. This approach theoretically levels the playing field, giving all homebuyers equal access to information and preventing the practice of "pocket listings," where agents keep certain properties off the MLS for various reasons.

Brian Boero, CEO of 1000Watt, a brand and marketing agency for real estate companies, encapsulates the sentiment behind the policy: "If you were to ask people, 'Should houses be hidden?' most people would say no. If you asked people, 'Should everybody be able to see the houses that are for sale on the market at any time and have, at least, access to them?' I think most people would say absolutely".

However, the policy has its critics. Opponents argue that it infringes on sellers' rights to market their homes as they see fit and may not always serve the best interests of all parties involved.

The Rise of Pocket Listings and Office Exclusives

Before the clear-cooperation policy, pocket listings were on the rise. These are properties that agents keep off the MLS, often marketing them privately or within exclusive networks. While pocket listings can offer benefits such as privacy for high-profile sellers or a way to test the market before a full launch, they also raise concerns about fair access to property information.

The clear-cooperation policy aimed to curb this practice, but it included a significant loophole: "office exclusives." This exception allows agents to market properties within their own brokerage without listing them on the MLS. Large brokerages have capitalized on this, offering services that promise sellers more control over their listing process.

Howard Hanna's "Find It First" program, for instance, allows sellers to "benefit from broad exposure without compromising on control," according to CEO Howard Hanna IV. This approach has led to accusations that the policy favors large brokerages at the expense of smaller firms and alternative listing services.

The Battle Lines: Industry Giants at Odds

The debate over clear cooperation has divided the real estate industry. On one side, executives from major brokerages like Compass and Anywhere Real Estate are pushing for the NAR to loosen or eliminate the rule. They argue that it restricts sellers' options and stifles innovation in property marketing.

Robert Reffkin, CEO of Compass, has been vocal in his opposition to the policy. Mauricio Umansky, a celebrity agent and CEO known for his appearances on reality TV shows, has even sued the NAR over his attempts to start an MLS alternative called the Property Listing Service (PLS).

On the other side, companies like Zillow and Redfin staunchly defend the policy. Glenn Kelman, Redfin's CEO, warns of the potential consequences of weakening clear cooperation: "The goal in weakening Clear Cooperation is to make being bigger matter — more than being better. That is the law of the jungle, masquerading as freedom".

The Impact on Consumers and the Market

The outcome of this debate will have significant implications for homebuyers and sellers. Proponents of clear cooperation argue that a centralized listing system benefits consumers by providing comprehensive access to available properties. They contend that fragmenting the market could lead to missed opportunities and potentially discriminatory practices.

Saul Klein, CEO of the San Diego Multiple Listing Service, emphasizes the collective benefit of the current system: "Everybody benefits when we all pool our listings, and we do so in a timely manner. And people are hurt, potentially, when we don't do that".

However, critics of the policy argue that it limits sellers' options and may not always result in the best outcomes. They point out that there are legitimate reasons why a seller might prefer a more private sales process, such as during a divorce or when selling a high-profile property.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

The clear-cooperation debate also intersects with legal and ethical concerns. The Department of Justice has signaled that the NAR's control over MLSes could be anticompetitive, potentially stifling the development of alternative listing platforms. This raises questions about whether the current system truly serves the best interests of consumers.

Conversely, supporters of clear cooperation argue that unrestricted off-MLS marketing could violate fair housing laws. Victor Lund of Wav Group asserts, "The fact that every listing is contributed to the MLS and that every consumer has access to that information is an enormous and overwhelming benefit to support fair housing. There is too much opportunity for housing discrimination without it".

The Future of Home Buying: A Fragmented Landscape?

As the NAR prepares to review the clear-cooperation policy, the real estate industry stands at a crossroads. The decision could reshape the home buying process for years to come. If the policy is loosened or eliminated, we may see a more fragmented market where buyers need to search multiple platforms and broker websites to find available properties.

Glenn Kelman of Redfin paints a vivid picture of this potential future: "If you haven't bought a home yet, there is nothing more unsettling than seeing a moving van outside a house that never showed up in any of your searches".

On the other hand, a revised policy could lead to more innovative marketing strategies and potentially give sellers greater control over how their properties are presented to the market.

The battle over America's hidden homes is more than just an industry squabble. It represents a fundamental question about the nature of the real estate market and how it should function in the digital age. As the NAR deliberates on the future of the clear-cooperation policy, stakeholders across the industry are watching closely.

The outcome of this debate will have far-reaching consequences for homebuyers, sellers, agents, and brokerages alike. It will determine whether we move towards a more open and transparent housing market or one that allows for more flexibility and privacy at the potential cost of equal access.

As the real estate landscape continues to evolve, one thing is certain: the way we buy and sell homes is changing. Whether that change will benefit the many or the few remains to be seen. For now, all eyes are on the NAR as they prepare to make a decision that could reshape the American dream of homeownership for generations to come.


Ad Banner
Advertisement by Open Privilege
Housing United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
HousingNovember 21, 2024 at 4:00:00 AM

The factors behind stubbornly high home prices

[UNITED STATES] In recent years, the American dream of homeownership has become increasingly elusive for many. Despite economic fluctuations and rising interest rates,...

Real Estate Singapore
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateNovember 18, 2024 at 3:30:00 PM

When HDB flat owners refuse to sell

[SINGAPORE] In Singapore's bustling real estate landscape, Housing and Development Board (HDB) flats stand as a cornerstone of the nation's public housing policy....

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateNovember 18, 2024 at 9:30:00 AM

How Trump's Middle East point man was once a real estate tycoon

[UNITED STATES] President-elect Donald Trump has appointed Steven Witkoff, a prominent real estate developer and longtime friend, as his special envoy to the...

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateNovember 18, 2024 at 5:30:00 AM

Homebuyer hopes and hurdles in Trump's housing agenda

[UNITED STATES] The American dream of homeownership has become increasingly elusive for many, with housing costs skyrocketing and inventory shortages plaguing markets across...

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateNovember 17, 2024 at 8:00:00 AM

The crucial role of accurate valuations in real estate transactions

[SINGAPORE] In the dynamic world of real estate, understanding the true value of your property is crucial for making informed decisions. Whether you're...

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateNovember 13, 2024 at 6:30:00 PM

Why builders are turning to rentals instead of buyers

[UNITED STATES] In an unexpected twist of the housing market, homebuilders across the United States find themselves sitting on a substantial inventory of...

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateNovember 10, 2024 at 9:30:00 AM

Rising HOA dues squeeze homeowners nationwide

[UNITED STATES] Homeowners across the United States are facing a new challenge in property ownership: rapidly increasing homeowners' association (HOA) dues. These rising...

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateNovember 5, 2024 at 7:30:00 AM

Why ownership doesn't guarantee residency

[UNITED STATES] Inheriting property is often seen as a straightforward process, but when it comes to cooperative apartments, or co-ops, the situation can...

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateNovember 3, 2024 at 11:30:00 PM

The modern revival of columned homes

[UNITED STATES] In the ever-evolving world of residential architecture, a surprising trend is making waves: the comeback of columned homes. Once considered a...

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateOctober 28, 2024 at 2:30:00 AM

Top destinations and motivations behind the Golden State's population shift

[UNITED STATES] California, long known as the Golden State, has been experiencing a significant population shift in recent years. The California exodus, a...

Real Estate United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
Real EstateOctober 27, 2024 at 5:30:00 PM

How Trump's immigration stance could reshape the housing market and construction industry

[UNITED STATES] As the 2024 presidential election approaches, former President Donald Trump's proposed immigration policies have sparked intense debate across various sectors of...

Ad Banner
Advertisement by Open Privilege
Load More
Ad Banner
Advertisement by Open Privilege