Ad Banner
Advertisement by Open Privilege

Why detention and suspension aren't enough to combat school bullying

Image Credits: UnsplashImage Credits: Unsplash
  • Detention and suspension alone are ineffective in addressing school bullying, often failing to tackle root causes and potentially exacerbating the problem.
  • A holistic approach combining counseling, restorative practices, and prevention programs is crucial for effectively combating bullying and promoting positive behavior change.
  • Creating a supportive school climate, involving parents and the community, and implementing consistent, equitable disciplinary strategies are key to long-term bullying prevention and intervention.

[WORLD] In recent years, the issue of school bullying has gained significant attention, prompting educators, parents, and policymakers to seek effective solutions. While traditional disciplinary measures like detention and suspension have long been the go-to responses for addressing bullying behavior, mounting evidence suggests that these approaches alone are insufficient in solving this complex problem.

The Limitations of Traditional Disciplinary Measures

Detention and suspension, once considered effective deterrents, are now being scrutinized for their limited impact on curbing bullying behaviors. These punitive measures often fail to address the root causes of bullying and may even exacerbate the problem in some cases.

Ineffectiveness of Suspension

Research has shown that out-of-school suspension is not only ineffective in improving future behavior but also disproportionately affects certain student groups. A study by Fabelo et al. (2011) found that students who received suspensions were more likely to be held back, drop out, or become involved in criminal activity.

Detention as a Short-Term Solution

While detention may seem like a logical consequence for misbehavior, its effectiveness in preventing bullying is questionable. Infantino and Little (2005) found that students perceived detention as one of the most effective deterrents. However, this perception doesn't necessarily translate to long-term behavioral change.

The Need for a Holistic Approach

Education Minister Chan Chun Sing's emphasis on rehabilitating bullies rather than solely punishing them marks a progressive step towards addressing the issue more comprehensively. A holistic approach that combines traditional disciplinary measures with counseling and restorative actions is crucial for effective intervention.

Counseling and Empathy Development

Counseling plays a vital role in helping students understand the impact of their behavior, develop empathy, and learn better ways to interact with peers. It provides an opportunity to unpack and address underlying issues that contribute to bullying behaviors, such as aggression modeled at home or in peer contexts.

Restorative Practices

Implementing restorative practices, such as mediated conversations between the bully and the victim, can promote accountability and healing. These approaches focus on repairing harm and rebuilding relationships rather than simply punishing the offender.

Prevention: A Key Component

While addressing existing bullying incidents is crucial, prevention should be a primary focus in schools. Implementing strong preventive programs can significantly reduce the likelihood of bullying occurrences.

Character and Citizenship Education

Singapore's Character and Citizenship Education (CCE) curriculum is an example of how schools can integrate anti-bullying efforts into their core educational programs. These initiatives aim to foster empathy, social skills, and emotional intelligence among students.

Creating a Culture of Care

Encouraging students to be "upstanders" – those who report or intervene when witnessing bullying – can help cultivate a culture of care and support within the school environment. This approach empowers students to take an active role in preventing bullying and creating a positive school climate.

The Role of Parents and Community

Addressing school bullying is not solely the responsibility of educators. Parents and the broader community play crucial roles in supporting anti-bullying efforts and reinforcing positive behaviors.

Parent-School Collaboration

Effective communication between schools and parents is essential to ensure consistency in addressing behavioral issues both at school and at home. Parents should be encouraged to reinforce positive behavior and support the school's rehabilitation efforts.

Community Involvement

Workshops conducted by social service agencies, such as the Singapore Children's Society, can reinforce students' core competencies and provide additional support in developing empathy and social-emotional skills.

Alternative Disciplinary Strategies

While traditional punitive measures may have limited effectiveness, alternative disciplinary strategies can provide more meaningful consequences for bullying behavior.

Logical Consequences

Implementing logical consequences that directly relate to the misbehavior can be more effective than generic punishments. For example, students who engage in bullying behavior might be required to complete community service or lose certain privileges.

Keeping Students Academically Engaged

It's crucial to keep students on track academically, even when addressing behavioral issues. Suspension often interrupts students' academic progress, increasing the likelihood of disengagement and dropout. Alternative in-school disciplinary measures can help maintain academic continuity while addressing behavioral concerns.

The Importance of Consistency and Equity

For any disciplinary approach to be effective, it must be consistently implemented and equitably applied across all student groups. Biggs et al. (2008) found that rules and sanctions have little impact on reducing future bullying or violent behaviors if they are not consistently enforced.

Addressing Underlying Factors

To effectively combat bullying, it's essential to understand and address the underlying factors that contribute to such behavior. Research has pointed to several reasons for school bullying, including aggressive behaviors observed at home or among peers.

The Role of School Climate

Creating a positive school climate is crucial in preventing and addressing bullying. Schools should focus on fostering an environment that promotes respect, inclusivity, and positive peer relationships.

Long-Term Impact of Effective Intervention

By implementing comprehensive anti-bullying strategies that go beyond traditional disciplinary measures, schools can create lasting change. Effective interventions not only address immediate bullying incidents but also contribute to students' personal growth and social-emotional development.

While detention and suspension have long been staples of school discipline, they are insufficient in addressing the complex issue of bullying. A more comprehensive approach that combines counseling, restorative practices, prevention programs, and community involvement is necessary to create meaningful change.

As Cheung Hoi Shan, Assistant Professor at the National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, states, "Addressing school bullying requires a multifaceted approach that goes beyond traditional disciplinary measures. By integrating counselling and restorative practices, schools can create an environment that not only deters bullying but also fosters personal growth and empathy".

By rethinking our approach to school discipline and bullying prevention, we can create safer, more supportive learning environments that benefit all students. It's time to move beyond punitive measures and embrace strategies that address the root causes of bullying while promoting empathy, accountability, and positive behavior change.


Ad Banner
Advertisement by Open Privilege
Careers
Image Credits: Unsplash
CareersMarch 28, 2025 at 12:00:00 PM

How Hong Kong colleges help graduates boost their careers in education

[WORLD] The educational scene in Hong Kong is rapidly changing, necessitating ongoing professional development for teachers and other workers. Not only do Master...

Politics United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
PoliticsMarch 26, 2025 at 6:30:00 AM

Judge halts ICE arrest of 21-year-old Columbia student

[UNITED STATES] In a landmark decision, a federal judge has ordered the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to stop trying to arrest...

Finance United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
FinanceMarch 25, 2025 at 3:30:00 AM

The impact of losing the Department of Education on financial aid

[UNITED STATES] The Department of Education (ED) plays a critical role in the U.S. educational system. From regulating student loans to ensuring equitable...

Loans United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
LoansMarch 22, 2025 at 1:00:00 AM

What Trump’s move to dismantle the Education Department means for student loans

[UNITED STATES] Former President Donald Trump signed an executive order aimed at dismantling the U.S. Department of Education (DOE) and shifting its functions...

Loans United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
LoansMarch 22, 2025 at 1:00:00 AM

Trump proposes SBA takeover of student loan management

[UNITED STATES] Former President Donald Trump has made a bold announcement regarding student loans, stating that the Small Business Administration (SBA) will be...

Loans United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
LoansMarch 20, 2025 at 11:30:00 PM

Impact of shutting down the Education Department on student loans

[UNITED STATES] The U.S. Department of Education is a cornerstone of the federal student loan system. With millions of Americans relying on federal...

Loans United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
LoansMarch 18, 2025 at 2:00:00 AM

Managing student loan payments after a layoff

[UNITED STATES] Facing a layoff can be one of the most stressful events in a person’s life. Along with the emotional and financial...

Politics United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
PoliticsMarch 14, 2025 at 8:00:00 AM

Protesters rally at Trump Tower over Columbia student’s arrest

[UNITED STATES] In recent weeks, a wave of protests erupted outside Trump Tower in New York City, drawing attention to the controversial arrest...

Politics United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
PoliticsMarch 13, 2025 at 6:30:00 AM

Columbia student to stay in Louisiana after ICE arrest

[UNITED STATES] A Columbia University student, Mahmoud Khalil, arrested by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), will remain in Louisiana under a judge's...

Loans United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
LoansMarch 12, 2025 at 12:00:00 AM

Trump opposes the Education Department's handling of student loans

[UNITED STATES] Former President Donald Trump recently expressed his opinion that the U.S. Department of Education should not be in charge of managing...

Economy United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
EconomyMarch 11, 2025 at 4:30:00 PM

How geopolitics affects Chinese students in America

[WORLD] The recent US visa ban bill has reignited concerns among Chinese students, who once again find themselves in the midst of geopolitical...

Politics United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
PoliticsMarch 11, 2025 at 8:30:00 AM

ICE arrest of Columbia student signals shift in campus politics

[UNITED STATES] The recent arrest of Mahmoud Khalil, a Columbia University student, by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) marks a critical turning...

Ad Banner
Advertisement by Open Privilege
Load More
Ad Banner
Advertisement by Open Privilege