[UNITED STATES] As President-elect Donald Trump prepares to return to the Oval Office, the U.S. housing market stands at a critical juncture. With affordability concerns at an all-time high and a persistent housing shortage plaguing the nation, industry experts are closely examining how Trump's proposed policies could reshape the real estate landscape. This comprehensive analysis delves into the potential impacts of Trump's presidency on the housing market, exploring both opportunities and challenges that lie ahead.
The Current State of the Housing Market
Before diving into Trump's potential influence, it's crucial to understand the current state of the U.S. housing market. The nation faces a significant housing shortage, with the National Association of Realtors reporting a deficit of 4 million homes by mid-2023. This shortage has contributed to skyrocketing home prices and a crisis in affordability, making homeownership an increasingly elusive dream for many Americans.
Jim Tobin, leader of the National Association of Home Builders, emphasizes the gravity of the situation: "It's clear that the prescription for this crisis is building". Despite a slight uptick in new home construction, the market struggles to meet the overwhelming demand, leaving a substantial gap in available properties for potential buyers.
Trump's Vision for Housing Affordability
President-elect Trump has declared his intention to tackle the housing affordability crisis head-on. During a news briefing on August 15, he stated, "We're going to open up tracks of federal land for housing construction. We need housing for people who can't afford what's going on now". This commitment to increasing housing supply aligns with industry experts' recommendations for addressing the current shortage.
Key Policy Proposals and Their Potential Impact
1. Deregulation to Enhance Affordability
Trump's campaign has strongly emphasized reducing regulations and permit requirements in the housing sector. At the Economic Club of New York on September 5, he boldly claimed, "We will eliminate regulations that drive up costs with the goal of cutting the cost of a new home in half". This approach builds on his first-term executive order aimed at eliminating regulatory barriers to affordable housing.
Dennis Shea, executive director at the Bipartisan Policy Center's J. Ronald Terwilliger Center for Housing Policy, suggests that this previous executive order could serve as a blueprint for future actions. The potential impact of deregulation is significant, considering that regulatory expenses currently account for about 24% of the cost of a single-family home and 41% for multifamily homes, according to Tobin.
2. Effects on the Construction Workforce
While Trump attributes rising home prices to increased illegal immigration during the Biden administration, his proposed immigration policies could have unintended consequences for the housing market. Experts warn that mass deportations could disrupt the construction industry, which heavily relies on immigrant labor.
Jacob Channel, a senior economist at LendingTree, explains, "Immigrants make up about 31% of the U.S. construction workforce. Disrupting this labor flow could send shockwaves through the home construction labor market". The industry has struggled to recruit native-born workers, with a 2017 NAHB survey showing only 3% of young American adults interested in construction trades.
3. Tariffs and Increased Building Costs
Trump's proposed tariffs, ranging from 10% to 20% on all imports and between 60% and 100% on Chinese goods, could significantly impact housing costs. Experts warn that tariffs on raw materials like lumber could substantially increase construction expenses.
Tobin elaborates, "Any tariffs that increase the cost of the products that flow to the job site are going to increase the cost of housing". With average construction costs for single-family homes around $392,241, according to ResiClub's analysis, the impact of tariffs could be substantial.
Potential Outcomes and Market Predictions
The homebuilding industry plans to construct approximately 1.1 million new single-family homes and 300,000 multifamily units in the coming year, according to Tobin. While this represents an increase in construction, it may not be sufficient to meet the current demand.
Daryl Fairweather, chief economist at Redfin, suggests that Trump's plan to use federal lands for housing development may not address the needs of densely populated areas, as these lands are often located in rural regions. This mismatch between supply and demand in urban centers could continue to pose challenges for housing affordability.
Expert Opinions and Market Analysis
Industry experts offer varied perspectives on the potential outcomes of Trump's housing policies:
Jacob Channel emphasizes the delicate balance between immigration policies and construction labor: "A reduction in available workers could lead to higher wages, which might be passed on to consumers through increased home prices".
Jim Tobin highlights the importance of regulatory reform: "Reducing these burdens could lower costs for consumers and potentially stimulate more housing development".
Daryl Fairweather cautions about the limitations of federal land development: "The proposed aid may not address the needs of densely populated areas that require the most assistance".
Challenges and Opportunities Ahead
While Trump's focus on increasing housing supply and reducing regulations may potentially boost affordability, several challenges remain:
Labor Shortages: The construction industry's reliance on immigrant labor could clash with stricter immigration policies, potentially slowing down housing development.
Cost Increases: Proposed tariffs on building materials could offset any savings gained from deregulation, potentially keeping housing costs high.
Urban-Rural Divide: The focus on developing federal lands may not adequately address housing needs in urban areas where demand is highest.
Market Volatility: Uncertainty surrounding policy implementation could lead to fluctuations in mortgage rates and housing market stability.
As President-elect Trump prepares to take office, the U.S. housing market stands at a crossroads. His proposed policies offer both potential solutions and challenges to the ongoing affordability crisis. While efforts to increase supply and reduce regulations could provide relief, the impact of immigration restrictions and tariffs on the construction industry remains a concern.
Ultimately, the success of Trump's housing policies will depend on their implementation and the ability to balance competing interests within the real estate sector. As the market evolves under the new administration, industry professionals, policymakers, and potential homebuyers will need to stay informed and adaptable to navigate the changing landscape of U.S. housing.
WhatsApp
Instagram
Threads
